ORDER NO. 19322 RESOLUTION ON PROTECTION FROM LIABILITY FOR DAMAGES INCURRED OR ARISING FROM THE USE OF INMATE LABOR On this the 22nd day o£ January 1990, upon motion made by Commissioner Holekamp, seconded by Commissioner Baldwin, the Court unaniaously approved a resolution supporting State Representative M. A. Taylor's efforts to have the following language or language to the same effect, added to Articles 43.09 and 43.10 0£ the Code o£ Criminal Procedure: "A sheriff, employee of a sherlff's department, member o£ the county commissioners' court, or county employee is not liable for damages arising from an act or failure to act by the Sheriff, employee o£ a sheriff's department, member o£ the county commissioners' court or county employee in connection with manual labor required to be performed by a defendant under this section i£ the act or failure to act was performed in an official capacity and was not criminal or malicious in nature. " RESOLUTION WIBrREAS: The overcrowded condition of county jails has placed a great burden and expense on Kerr County, like most Texas Counties in housing and caring for prisoners; and WHEiREAS: The Counties in the State of Texas would benefit greatly from the use of county prisoners to work on county projects, roads and improvements, so that the county would save the expense of hiring labor to perform these functions and could thereby recoup some of the expense incurred in housing and feeding the prisoners; and WHEiREAS: Articles 43.09 and 43.10 of the Code of Criminal procedure provide counties with authority, through their sheriff, to put inmates to work on county projects, roads and improvements; and WI~REAS: Due to concern over potential personal liability for injuries to or caused by prisoners, many Commissioners' Court and Sheriff's departments are hesitant to take full advantage of inmate labor; and WfiE;i2F.AS: The Commissioners' Court of Kerr County hereby supports and endorses the efforts of State Representative M. A.Taylor to speak to this problem by his request that certain amendments be added to the Code of Criminal Procedure during the next legislative session; NOW, THEiitEFOiftE: The Commissioners' Court of Kerr County, Texas does hereby agree with and support the effort to have the following language or language to the same effect, added to Articles 43.09 and 43.10 of the Code of Criminal Procedure: "A sheriff, employee of a sheriffs department, member of the county commissioners' court, or county employee is not liable for damages arising from an act or failure to act by the sheriff, employee of a sheriffs department, member of the county commissioners' court or county employee in connection with manual labor required to be performed by a defendant under this section if the act or failure to act was performed in an official capacity and was not criminal or malicious in nature. Signed and placed under the seal of Kerr County, Texas by the Commissioners' Court of said County this the ,j~.~/ day of January 1990. ~ ~~ D. ED ARDS Co ty Judge R. GO ON MOR Commissioner -Precinct IiLL'~~ AMP Commissioner -Precinct BILL~~ Commissioner - ecinct 2 / ~. ~. 1 __1~~~ H. A. " USTER" B WIN Commissioner -Precinct 4 a~ u ... DANNY R. EDWARDS COUNTY JUDGE, KERR COUNTY KERRVILLE, TEXAS 78028 PHONE' 512 257-6711 January 22, 1990 Honorable M. A. Taylor State Representative, Dist. 55 6801 Sander, Suite 145 P. 0. Box 7801 Waco, Texas 76714 Dear Representative Taylor: Enclosed ie a Reaolutlon passed by the Commissioners' Court of Kerr County, Texas, in Special Session on January 22, 1990 in support of the proposed legislation to be introduced in Special Session by you. We feel it would be in the beat interest of the State of Texas, and of the counties comprising the political subdivisions thereof, for there to be express statutory protection of sheriff e, their officers, deputies and employees, county commissioners, and county employees from liability for damages incurred or arising from the use of inmate labor upon public works. We thank yo~ very much ~u s tru y ~.~ DANNY R~DWARDS Kerr County Judge DRE:tch Enclosure for your efforts in this matter. cc: Com. Ray Meadows Gov. William P. Clements, Jr. Rep. Harvey Hilderbrand Sen. Bill Sims JAN 17 RECD January 19, 1990 Dear County Official, I am formally writing to you and asking for your support of this proposed legislation be be introduced in special session by Rep. M. A. Taylor of McLennan County. The concensus of opinion is that it would be good to have a resolution of your support sent to your local Representative or Senator on this upcoming legislation or sent back to us and we will forward to Rep. M. A. Taylor. This would be a great opportunity to remove some liability off County Officials and the Sheriff Office and benefit each respective county and possibly reduce the jail population. Yours truly Y MEA~~~/L~ ounty Commissioner cc: Rep. M. A. Taylor Gov. William P. Clements, Jr. Sheriff Association TAC All Commissioners' Courts NOT PRINTED OR MAILED AT COUNTY EXPENSE. RAY MEADOWS COUNTY COMMISSIONER, PCT.4 P. O. BOX 648 WACO, TEXAS 76703-0648 757-5064 ~~~.~~~ January 9, 1990 Honorable M. A. Taylor State Representative, Dist. 55 6801 Sanger, Suite 145 P. U. Box 7801 Waco, Texas 76714 Dear Representative Taylor: I am writing this letter on behalf of the people of McLennan County to request that certain amendments be added to the Code of Criminal Procedure during the next legislative session. As I am sure you are aware, the overcrowded condition of county jails in this state has placed a great burden on the counties of this state. McLennan County, like most Texas counties, incurs enormous expense each year in housing aqd caring for prisoners. Speaking for McLennan County, I believe the county would benefit greatly from the use of county prisoners to work on county projects, roads and improvements. In this manner the county would save the expense of hiring labor to perform these functions and could thereby recoup some of the expense incurred in housing and feeding the prisoners. Articles 43.09 and 43.10 of the Code of Criminal Procedure provide counties with authority, through their sheriff, to put inmates to work on county projects, roads and improvements. Unfortunately, due to concern over potential personal liability for injuries to or caused by prisoners, many commissioners' courts and sheriff's departments in this state are hesitant to take full advantage of inmate labor. The protections provided by the Doctrine of Qualified Official Immunity in the State of Texas are not sufficient to allay these fears and, to a great extent, the Doctrine may not provide sheriffs, their employees, or county commissioners with the protection from personal liability they deserve and need. Nl1T PPINTFII n8 uAll Fn dT f!]IINTV EXPENSE RAY MEADOWS COUMY COMM13810NER, PCI: 4 P. O. BOX 848 WACO,TEXAS 76703-0648 ~s~-sass _! Honorable M. A. Taylor Page Two January 9, 1990 Therefore, it would be in the best interest of the State of Texas, and of the counties comprising the political subdivisions thereof, for there to be express statutory protection of sheriffs, their officers, deputies and employees, county commissioners, and county employees from liability for damages incurred or arising from the use of inmate labor upon public works. Thus, as an elected county commissioner of the people of McLennan County, I would request that the following language, or language substantially similar and to the same effect, be added to Articles 43.09 and 43.10 of the Code of Criminal Procedure: A sheriff, employee of a sheriff's department, member of the county commissioner's court, or county employee is not liable for damages arising from an act or failure to act by the sheriff, employee of a sheriff's department, member of the county commissioner's court or county employee in connection with manual labor required to be performed by a defendant under this section if the act or failure to act was performed in an official capacity and was not criminal or malicious in nature. Such a provision would provide the county commissioners and sheriffs of this state with greater protection from personal liability and would give counties greater incentive to utilize inmate labor. Your prompt attention to this matter is greatly appreciated by the people of McLennan County. I Sin rely, ~16u.~- a Meadows cLennan County Commissioner Precinct 4