p8iya~ /. ~ COMMISSIONERS' COURT AGENDA REQUEST PLEASE FURNISH ONE ORIGINAL AND NINE COPIES OF THIS REQUEST AND DOCUMENTS TO BE REVIEWED BY THE COURT. MADE BY: Barbara Nemec OFFICE: Treasurer MEETING DATE: August 14, 2006 TIME PREFERRED: 9:45 A.M. SUBJECT: Consider, Discuss and take appropriate action on proposed plan provision changes for TCDRS 2007 Plan Year. EXECUTIVE SESSION REQUESTED: (PLEASE STATE REASON] NAME OF PERSON ADDRESSING THE COURT: Barbara Nemec/TCDRS Representative ESTIMATED LENGTH OF PRESENTATION: 10 mins. IF PERSONNEL MATTER -NAME OF EMPLOYEE: Time for submitting this request for Court to assure that the matter is posted in accordance with Title 5, Chapter 551 and 552, Government Code, is as follows: Meeting scheduled for Mondays: 5:00 P.M. previous Tuesday. THIS REQUEST RECEIVED BY: THIS REQUEST RECEIVED ON: All Agenda Requests will be screened by the County Judge's Office to determine if adequate information has been prepared for the Court's formal consideration and action at time of Court Meetings. Your cooperation will be appreciated and contribute towards you request being addressed at the earliest opportunity. See Agenda Request Rules Adopted by Commissioners' Court. Kerr County, #232 Rate information for proposed plan provision changes Plan year 2007 Current Plan Proposed Proposed Proposed Plan I Plan 2 Plan 3 Plan Provisions: Employee deposit rate 7% 7% 7~0 7%0 Ma¢hing rate 190%0 190°% 190% 190% Past and future deposits /furore deposits" Prior service credit 145% 145% 145% 145% Vesting 8 years 8 years 8 years 8 years Rule of 75 75 75 75 Eligible at X years and any age 3U years 2U years 20 years 30 years COLA"' N/A Credit tot military service Yes Yes Yes Yes Pazrial lump sum No Yes No Yes Buyback""' N/A No No No Plan Rates: ]. Normal cost rate 6.16 % 6.40'Yo 6.22% 6.32°/ 2. UAAL raze 1.96yo 2.14% 2.U4% 2.05 3. Total required rate kr 2007*"** 8.12% 8.54% 8.26% 8.37% 4. Rate difference between proposed and current plan 0.42% 0.14% 0.25% 5. Elected rate Plan Assets & Liabilities: G. Present value of furore benefits $ 22,543,047 $ 22,7°3.801 $ 22,522,R35 $ 22,763,567 ~ Present value of future normal cost contributions $ 4,004,064 $ 4,055,705 $ 3.899,017 $ 4,140,351 8. Actuarial vccrued liabilities (Line 6 Line 7) $ 18,538,983 $ 18,718,096 $ 18,623.818 $ 18,623.216 9. Actuarial value ofassecs $ 16,152,206 $ 16,152,206 $ 16,152.206 $16,152,206 10. Unfunded or (overfunded) actuarial accrued liability [UAAL or (OAAL)] (Line 8 -Liue 91 8 2,386,777 $ 2,565.890 $ 2.471,612 $ 2,471,O1U ] L Funded ratio (Line 9/Line 8) 87 % 86"/0 87% 87% 12. Amortization period 20.0 years 20.0 years 20.0 years 20.0 years ' The matching rate can never be lowered for empbyee deposits that have already Fern made. "The last COLA adopted was a CPl-based 50°/n COLA effective 2005. "' The last buyback was authorized in 2003. "" Required rate for 2006: 7.60. Please contact TCDRS if you have any questions or for any additional information regarding changing benefit plan options. 800-823-7782 • WWW.TCDRS.ORG lun. 22,2006 Texas County and District Retirement System Subdivision Plan Data for Kerr County Plan Data as of 1/1/2006 Type of Plan: Annually Determined Contribution Rate (ADCR) Plan Employee Deposit Rate: 7.00% of gross compensation Employer Deposit Rate: 7.60% of gross compensation Maximum Contribution Waiver: Authorized by this subdivision. Optional Group Term Life Deposit Rate: 0.27% of gross compensation Current Matching Rate: 190% of employee deposits and interest. Matched at retirement. Prior Service Credit Allocation Rate: 145% of accumulated prior service credit. Employer Participation Date: October 01, 1970 Special Purchase Eligibility: Prememberehip Credit: Nol Authorized by this subdivision Military Service Credit: Authorized by this subdivision. -Service Requirement: 6 years. Special Enrollment Eligibility: Prosecuting Attorney Participation: Not Authorized by this subdivision District Judge Participation: Not Authorized by this subdivision Service Retirement Eligibility: 30 years of service at any age. Age 60 and 6 years of service. Rule of 75 Disability Retirement Eligibility Must be incapacitated for any gainful employment Incapacity is likely to be permanent If the person has less than 8 years of service, the incapacity must be the direct result of injuries sustained during membership by exlemal and violent means as a direct and proximate result of the pertormanra of duty. Survivor Annuity Death Benefit Eligibility: a years of service. Optional Group Term Life Eligibility: Date of death must be durinc or after the month of January. 2004. Authorized only for emolovees. CPI-Based Benefit Increase: Nol Authorized by this subdivision. Flat Rate Benefit Increase: Not Authorized by this subdivision. Buyback: Not Authorized for this plan year. Partial lump Sum Distribution: Not Authorized by this subdivision. TCDRS EmployerNumber: 232 Report Name: SubPlanFor2000.rpt October l$ 2005 11:13 am RETIREMENT PLAN ASSESSMENT FOR PLAN YEAR 2007 Kerr County - 232 Kerr County, #232 Retirement plan assessment for plan year 2007 It's that time of year again time to look at your TCDRS retire- NEXT STEPS ment plan and decide whether or not your benefits are adequate I. If you are not considering any plan changes ... and affordable. This plan assessment will give you an overview of return the enrlosed autharrzation by Dec. IS, 2006. the benefits you currently provide. It also includes estimates on how 2. If you are only adopting a COLA or elected rate . much it will cos[ to provide these benefits in 2007. return the enclosed authorization by Der. 15. 2006. If you ate interested in adding to or changing your plan provisions for 2007, please contact your TCDRS Communications representative by Oct. 02, 2006. We will send you cost and benefit informs[ion on any changes you are considering. If you are satisfied with your currem plan, please return the enclosed authorization by Dec. 15, 2006. If you have ques[ions, contact your TCDRS Communications representative at 800-823-7782. 3. If you are considering changing or adding other plan provisions ... rantact TCDRS at 800-823-7782 by Oct. 02, 2006. We will be happy to rend you the rates and authorization for the plan rhanger you are conridering. KEV DATES Oct. 02, 2000 • Contact your TCDRS Communications representative by [his date if you are considering any changes to your plan provisions. • Deadline to contact TCDRS in writing if you are considering a decrease in your employee deposit rate. • Deadline to contact TCDRS in writing if you are considering authorizing a buyback. Dec. 15, 2006 Send in your authorization to TCDRS confirming your 2007 plan provisions. 800-827-7182 * WWW.TCORS.ORC I Apr. 12,2008 YOUR BENEFITS Basic Benefit Provisions: Employee deposit rate 7% Matching rate - 190°rfi Prior rervice credit - 145°k Retirement Eligibility: Age 60 with 8yearr of service Any age with 30 yearr of rervice Rule of75 (age plot yeah ofservire equals 75) Survivor Annuity Death Benefit. Cos[-of-Living Adjustments (COLAs) for retirees: Your last adopted COLA war a 50% CPI-based COLA in 2005. Optional Benefit Provisions: • Military service- If your employees have earned at least 8 years of service with TCDRS, they can be credited with up to 60 mon[hs of military service. • Buyback -You last passed a buyback authorization in 2003. Beneficiary is eligible for a monthly payment when member hat four years ofservice. WHATYOU ARE PROVIDING Under your plan, each employee makes deposits into his or her personal TCDRS accoun[ by paying in a percentage of each paycheck. Employee accounts earn 7% interes[ each year, which is compounded annually based on the account balance a[ the beginning of the year. If one of your employees chooses to receive a retiremem benefit, TCDRS adds the employee's personal accoun[ balance to matching and other credits you provide as an employer. We then convert [ha[ sum into a monthly annuity, payable for life. The following chart shows the estimated TCDRS benefit as a percentage of final salary prior to retirement for a new hire: Izovs looms anst G0~ 40YO 20°/0 Ofi Assumptions Employees are new hires and will work for you tmril reriremenr. Your current plan provisions will remain in effect through employee's reriremenr. • Current laws governing'I'CDRS will continue as they are. • Graded salary scales give bigger raises early in rareers, with smaller raises later in careers (see Summary Valuation Report at www.ttdrs.org). • Based on single-life standard benefit. b of final n 800-823-7782 + W W W.TCDRS.ORG 2 Apr. 12, 2008 Hired at 55 Himd at 50 Hired at 45 Hired at 40 Hired at 35 Retired at GS Retired at 65 Retired at GS Retired at GS Retired at GS YOUR COSTS Your employer contribution rate represents the percentage of payroll your organization needs to contribute [o fund future beneFits for your Curren[ employees, former employees and retirees. To determine your plan cost for 2007: Your calculated contribution rate for 2007 Plus the rate for any COLA granted + Total Required Rate (Add the two rates together) Divide by 100 to convert % to number Multiply by your 2007 estimated compensation for enrolled employees x Your estimated annual plan cost = Examplc: County X bas a calculated contrrbution rate of7~. They have elected a COLA that will add 0.25% to their tort. With compenration for enrolled employees totaling $1,000.000, their annual cart would be calculated ar follows: County X'r calculated contribution rate 700 °k Plus the rate for any COLAgranted + .25 Total required rate 725 °6 Divide by 100 to convert 4o to number .0725 COLAs must be re-authorized each year. They are not "aummatic". If you wish to authorize a COLA for the next plan year, you can estimate the cost based on the schedule of rates below: 30% 40% B SOoh c GO% v 70~ ~ 1~ a U c 80% 2% 90oh w 3% 100% 4% ~ ~ of payroll of payroll Compensaton for enrolled employees x 1,000,000 County X'r ertimated annual plan tort $ 72,500 For a historical perspective, below is a record of your ra[e his[ory over the last four years. 10% 8% ^ Beginning Year Rate 6% ^ Ending Year Rate 4% 2% 0% 2003-2004 2004-2005 2005-2006 2006-2007 REASONS FOR RATE CHANGE Beginning Rate 7.92No 7.97% 7.90^h 7.60% Plan Changes Adopted 0.00 0.29 0.00 N/A Investment Remrn U.19 -020 0.00 0.00 Elected Rate/Lump Sum U.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 Demographic/Other Changes -0.14 -0.16 -0.12 -0.08 Assumptions/Methods 0.00 0.00 -0.18 0.60 Ending Rate 7.97% 7.90^k 7.60°.6 8.1296 A complae Summary Valuation Report for the Dec. 31, 2005 valuation is available on the Web. 800-823-7782 + W W W.TODRS.ORG 3 Apr. 12, 2008 Kerr County, #232 Rate information for proposed plan provision changes Plan year 2007 Current Plan Lowering Partial Both EIIgIbllity Lump Sum Plan Provisions: Employee deposit rate 7% 7°k 7% 7% Matching race 190% 190°h 190% 190Po Past and furore deposits /furore deposits* Prior service credit 145% 145Wo 145% 145% Vesting 8 years 8 years 8 years 8 years Rule of 75 75 75 75 Eligible at X years and any age 30 years 20 years 30 years 2U years COLA'* N/A Credit for military service Yes Yes Yes Yes Partial lump sum No No Yes Yes Buyback"' N/A No No No Plan Rates: L Normal cost rate 6.16% 6.22^/0 6.32"h 6.40% 2. UAAL rate 1.96""/u 2.04% 2.05°Po 2.14% 3. Total required rate for 2007'"*' 8.12°k 8.26% 8.37% 8.54°k 4. Rate difference between proposed and current plan 0.14% 0.25% 0.42°k 5. Elected race Plan Assets & Liabilities: 6. Present value of future benefits $ 22,543,047 $ 22,522,835 $ 22,763,567 $ 22,773.801 7. Present value of future normal cost contributions $ 4,004,064 $ 3,899,017 $ 4,140,351 $ 4,055,705 8. Actuarial accrued liabilities (Line 6 -Line 7) $ 18,538,983 $ 18,623,818 $ 18,623,216 $ 18,718,096 9. Actuarial value of assets $ 16,152,206 $ 16,152,206 $ 16,152,206 $ 16,152,206 10. Unfunded or (overfunded) actuarial accrued liability [UAAL or (OAAL)] (Line 8 -Line 9) $ 2.386,777 $ 2,471,612 $ 2,471,010 $ 2,565.890 11. Funded ratio (Line 9/Line 8) 87Wo 87% 87% 86% 12. Amoaiaation period 20.0 years 20.0 years 20.0 years Z0.0 years 'The matching rate can never be lowered for employee deposirs that have already been made. '* The last COLA adopted was a CPl-based 50 % COLA effective 2005. '*" The last buyback was authorized in 2003. *'** Required ram for 2006: 7.60%. Please wntaa'PCDRS if you have any questions or for any additional information regarding changing bene£t plan options. 800-823-7/82 • WWW.TCDRS.ORG Aug. 11, 2008 1. How your county pays for its retirement benefits 2.The retirement benefits your commissioners court may select or alter n~s~a i L zone The Commissioners Court (current and past) established a retirement benefit plan for county employees. The county's contributions to TCDRS become part of the trust and are used to payout county employees' annuities. The more benefits you promise to county employees, the more you contribute to save for those benefits down the road. aia~si n. zoos 2 While the county is saving for retirement benefits, * County employees will make benefit decisions * The economy will grow stronger and weaker * Future courts will raise and lower retirement benefits These decisions affect what the county will have available to provide benefits. Each year TCDRS compares your county's savings (projected assets) to the benefits promised to county employees (projected future payouts). This is why your contribution rate either decreases or increases annually. Comparing ASSETS (current and projected future assets) to LIABILITIES (current and future payouts) a~e~~>>. zoos 3 1. Expected employee withdrawals 2. Expected payroll growth ~ ~ ., . , 3. Expected return on investments Assume an 8% return, that's 7% to employees and 9% to county 4. Expected retirements Auau411.10J9 1. Actual employee withdrawals ~ ~ 2. Actual payroll growth Short-term employee Long-term 3. Actual return on investments employee 4. Actual retirements 5. Actual benefit changes, if you made any - Addition of benefits - Changes to existing benefits Au,~,~,,.z~ 4 * An annual lump-sum contribution helps pay down your UAAL (annual payment) * Electing a higher monthly rate helps pay down your UAAL and may insure a stable budget amount (monthly payments) - These allow you to pre-fund benefits - They also act as a "cushion" against future negative plan experience AupuA 11, 2C~ 5 m 4.00% + r d ~ ~ 3.00% to 3.99% i= ~ ~a a ~ 2.00% to 2.99% Q m `o ~ 1.00% to 1.99% a a a .06% to .99% 12 Basic Benefit Provisions: * Employee deposit rate - 7% * Matching rate -190% Retirement Eligibility: * Age 60 with 8 years of service * Any age with 30 years of service (looking at lowering to 20) OptbrtiilBeufeiH ~~~rears of service equals 75) * Military Service -Once an employee has earned S years of * Pa is Lump Sum Distribution -Allows employee to withdraw part ret~,r,,;~r TCDRS account balance as a lump sum at retirement. * You last adopted a COLA (CPI Based) in 2005a~~~~~.~~ Age + Years of Service = 75 7 Employer must authorize this option. A lump sum payment in any amount up to 100% of retiree's personal contributions and interest NOTE: This will reduce retiree's monthly pension payment Subject to 20% Federal W/H possible 10% Early Withdrawal Penalty AuAUS111~ R0."H re Annuity Purchase Rate • Life Expectancy • Payout Option • 7% interest A'NUe111.2L~ 8 it You choose to keep or change the rate at which employees' savings are matched at retirement * The matching rate you select is the percentage applied to employee savings at the time of retirement. You are saving in advance to provide this match. * You may change a matching rate up or down between 100% and 250% in 5% intervals * Now, matching increases may be made as forward-only increases mean n, zoos 1 Final Salary ^ 150% Matching Rate ^ 175 % Matching Rate ^ 200 % Matching Ra[e Note. This asmmes thaz your gr:plgysss~siYne ]% into their TCDRS rmrcment plan. For evarr~le. An employee that stazts az ag<45, deposits ] % monfily, and then rtires at age 65 haz pm in 20 years of service. their salary replacement appears in tfie 20 year columns. Therefore, the amount replaced will vary according to your matching raze. ew..a.aaev.+a..mm..y~a.s.wa.n..e=ss~. m,.: v.. i.swx. v..e_na.a, v.u vm.. v. ~a seenr.v •auu. v.. ze_axcx 9 Cost of Living Adjustments (COLAs) are annuity increases for retirees There are 2 types of COLAs you may adopt annually: * Flat-rate - a flat percentage of increase applied to each retiree's monthly annuity (capped at 4% for 2007) * CPI-based - a percentage from 30% - 100% designed to help each retiree "catch up" from the effects of inflation Auau5111, ]0.'H Counties can now rehire retirees without a pension freeze * IRS requires that the retirement be bona fide (IRS qualification issues may arise if county abuses this right) * Employees you choose to hire back must have at least one full calendar month break in service ~9u& 11, $C[8 10 ~r Employees should be classified as temporary or non-temporary for TCDRS purposes * Definition of `temporary' is left to the good-faith determination of each TCDRS county -Temporary: Is the position known to have an end date? - Non-temporary: Is the person expected to be in the position for the foreseeable future? Deadline is Jan.1, 2007 if you signed a waiver to delay enrolling through 2006 ~e~:m, zoos 11