COMMISSIONERS' COURT WORKSHOP AGENDA MONDAY, AUGUST 9, 2010, 1:00 P.M. COMMISSIONERS' COURTROOM KERR COUNTY COURTHOUSE KERRVILLE, TEXAS 78028 THIS NOTICE IS POSTED PURSUANT TO THE TEXAS OPEN MEETINGS ACT. (TITLE 5, CHAPTER 551, GOVERNMENT CODE AND TITLE 5, CHAPTER 552, GOVERNMENT CODE.) This Commissioners' Court will hold a workshop at 1:00 P.M., Monday, August 9, 2010, in the Kerr County Commissioners' Courtroom, Kerr County Courthouse. Review and discuss FY 2010 -11 Budgets and fiscal, capital expenditure and personnel matters related thereto including, but not limited to, Cost of Living Adjustment, Salary Considerations, Staffing Levels, Health Benefits and Insurance. Filed 5 Day o A.D. 2010 JANNETT PIEPER, KE CO. CLERK TIME By!! I ! _' !J& JA HRA History 168 78 28 274 20% less than 600 1200 1800 08 -09 Year EE +Spouse OR Total 2009/2010 EE Only EE +Child(ren) EE +Family Total 2010 Carry Over Liability /Cost $100,800.00 $93,600.00 $50,400.00 $244,800.00 $118,527.07 $363,327.07 167 78 35 280 15% less than 600 1200 1800 07 -08 Year EE +Spouse OR Total 2008/2009 EE Only EE +Child(ren) EE +Family Total 2010 Carry Over Liability /Cost $100,200.00 $93,600.00 $63,000.00 $256,800.00 $196,465.10 $453,265.10 172 90 14 276 600 1800 1800 EE +Spouse OR EE +Child(ren) Total 2007/2008 EE Only OR EE +Family Retiree Total 2010 Carry Over Liability /Cost $103,200.00 $162,000.00 $25,200.00 $290,400.00 $239,828.70 $530,228.70 Trend began with a 20% increase in expense 08 -09 and then another 15% in 09 -10. Liabilty Cost has decreased almost $200,000 due to increased USE and not being carried over. So the liability is down but the actual expense is $200K higher. • j HRA Card - Cost Scenarios 168 78 28 274 600 1200 1800 EE +Spouse 2009/2010 OR Total Actual EE Only EE +Child(ren) EE +Family Total 2010 Carry Over Liability /Cost $100,800.00 $93,600.00 $50,400.00 $244,800.00 $118,527.07 $363,327.07 Scenario 1 - Employee Only HRA 274 274 600 1200 1800 EE +Spouse OR Total 2010/2011 EE Only EE +Child(ren) EE +Family Total 2010 Carry Over Liability /Cost $164,400.00 $0.00 $0.00 $164,400.00 $118;527.07 $282,927.07 Potential Savings $80,400.00 Used 09 -10 Carryover in its entirity as you cannot split it out. Carryover is potentially high as EE +child and EE +Spouse and EE +Family is included. Scenario 2 - Employee Only, No Carryover 274 274 600 1200 1800 EE +Spouse OR Total 2010/2011 EE Only EE +Child(ren) EE +Family Total 2010 Carry Over Liability /Cost $164,400.00 $0.00 $0.00 $164,400.00 $0.00 $164,400.00 Potential Savings $198,927.07 Scenario 3 - Remove Co -Pay Option on HRA card 168 78 28 274 600 1200 1800 EE +Spouse 2009/2010 OR Total Actual EE Only EE +Child(ren) EE +Family Total 2010 Carry Over Liability /Cost CANNOT give this information as DPAS is attempting to split out this information. 1W1 SCRIPT CARE, LTD. Clinical Services 6 380 Folsom Drive * Beaumont, TX 77706 Customer Service 1-800 -880 -9988 or Fax 409 - 832,3109 SCRIPT CARE, LTD. www.scriptcare.com CVR Jr P LAJ Kerr County Alternative Tier Medication Therapeutic Alternatives Aciphex $223.56 omeprazole $50.69 pantoprazole $75.01 lansoprazole $130.60 Celebrex $151.21 meloxicam $20.98 diclofenac $34.16 Crestor $123.53 simvastatin $19.19 pravastatin $10.12 lovastatin $25.41 Kapidex $115.62 omeprazole $50.69 pantoprazole $75.01 lansoprazole $130.60 Lipitor $110.48 simvastatin $19.19 pravastatin $10.12 lovastatin $25.41 Nexium $176.67 omeprazole $50.69 pantoprazole $75.01 lansoprazole $130.60 Vytorin $108.64 simvastatin $19.19 pravastatin $10.12 lovastatin $25.41 The costs identified above are for all strengths of the product for a 30 day supply. Cost will vary based on pharmacy and strength. Alternative Tier Medications Ca. $55.00 (Retail) OR Alternative $5.00 Generic e Alternative Tier Therapeutic Ft-A Medications . Alternatives Aciphex omeprazole, pantoprazole, lansoprazole Celebrex meloxicam, nonsteroidal anti - inflammatory agents Crestor simvastatin, pravastatin, lovastatin Kapidex omeprazole, pantoprazole, lansoprazole Lipitor simvastatin, pravastatin, lovastatin Nexium omeprazole, pantoprazole, lansoprazole Vytorin simvastatin, pravastatin, lovastatin Over The Counter (OTC) Zero Copavment Meds Current New Prilosec OTC (20mg) Prilosec OTC (20mg) Pepcid AC OTC (10mg and 20mg) Pepcid AC OTC (10mg and 20mg) Pepcid Complete OTC (10mg) Pepcid Complete OTC (10mg) Zantac OTC (75mg and 150mg) Zantac OTC (75mg and 150mg) Tagament HB (200mg) Tagament HB (200mg) Axid AR (75mg) Axid AR (75mg) Claritin OTC (10mg) Claritin OTC (10mg) Alavert OTC (10mg) Alavert OTC (10mg) Loratidine OTC (10mg) Loratidine OTC (10mg) Zyrtec OTC /Cetrizine OTC (effective Zyrtec OTC /Cetrizine OTC (effective 3/12/2008) 3/12/2008) Omeprazole ***N EW*** Prevacid OTC ** *NEW*** Nicotine Replacement Patches * *NEW*** Eva Hyde Page 2 8/9/2010 • Recommended Modifications to the Prescription Plan for 2010 Commissioners Court 12 -28 -09 (Approved Court Order #31579) OTC (add these] Omeprazole Prevacid OTC Nicotine Replacement Patches Tobacco Cessation Plan Limit to $500.00 Bi- Annual with a Lifetime Maximum Benefit of $2000.00 which includes OTC $0.00 Co- pay Items. (Bi- Annual = every other year) Non Formulary Cost SCL Diabetic Program (Change to SCL) Mandatory Program - currently have 19 diabetics acquiring medication for diabetes yet only 9 acquired supplies. (See attachment "SCL Diabetic Program Letter ") Co -Pay Structure (Change Plan) Current Plan New Plan Retail (30 -Day Supply) $10.00 Generic $5.00 $20.00 Formulary $25.00 $35.00 Non - formulary $40.00 $0.00 Alternative $55.00 Current Plan New Plan Mail (90 -Day Supply) $20.00 Generic $10.00 (reduced $5.00 x 2 = $10) $25.00 Formulary $50.00 $40.00 Non - formulary $80.00 $0.00 Alternative $110.00 NOTE: Mail Plan is set up to be 2 retail copays for a 90 day supply. If the retail copay is $10.00, $10 x 2 = $20; $25 x 2 = $50 etc Current Plan New Plan Natl Diabetic PharmacyNDP $5.00 Generic SCL Pharmacy $0.00 $5.00 Formulary $5.00 $35.00 Non- formulary $35.00 Current Plan New Plan Specialty $20.00 Generic $10.00 $40.00 Formulary $45.00 $70.00 Non - formulary $75.00 LUH L P -E-: I° Eva Hyde Page 1 8/9/2010 SCRIPT CARE Pi ovicrIng the ihnt in Phorrnocy Bcneftts Services hiJvcanwtde Kerr County 2011 Modifications to Alternative Tier Over the last several months, there have been some new generics introduced into the market. These additions have created the opportunity to add to the existing alternative tier. As the generics mature in the market place and the number of manufacturers increase the price will continue to decrease. Based on data from 1/1/10 - 6/30/10 these are the projected differences in total cost (summation of plan cost and copay). Drug Members Affected Total Cost Alternative Product Total Cost Atacand 0 0 Losartan K $64.96 Atacand HCT 0 0 Losartan K/HCT $73.58 Avapro 0 0 Losartan K $64.96 Avalide 1 $102.43 Losartan K/HCT $73.58 Benicar 1 $59.90 Losartan K $64.96 Benicar HCT 3 $125.66 Losartan K/HCT $73.58 Cymbalta 7 $251.30 Venlafaxine ER $144.17 Diovan 0 0 Losartan K $64.96 Diovan HCT 5 $88.24 Losartan K/HCT $73.58 Micardis 0 0 Losartan K $64.96 Micardis HCT 2 $87.80 Losartan K/HCT $73.58 Pristiq 2 $221.00 Venlafaxine ER $144.17 Teveten 0 0 Losartan K $64.96 Teveten HCT 0 0 Losartan K/HCT $73.58 G 6 es --- c-e. . tbO 5c-2 -■ ('S -- 6 C t K1cwb C b I LJ ALTCt2 NAT (Ue Insurance Scenarios Scenario 1 Monthly Annually Total Families $ 450/55 28 450.00 5,400.00 151,200.00 Spouses $240/55 33 240.00 2,880.00 95,040.00 Children $ 250/55 40 250.00 3,000.00 120,000.00 366,240.00 Employee Only $55 155 55.00 660.00 102,300.00 Emp Contrib 119 55.00 660.00 78,540.00 180,840.00 Total Employee Contrib 547,080.00 HRA CARD /County Contrib 200,000.00 County Contribution 202,920.00 Total County Contribution 402,920.00 Scenario 2 Monthly Annually Total Families $600/60 28 600.00 7,200.00 201,600.00 Spouses $300/60 33 300.00 3,600.00 118,800.00 Children $300/60 40 300.00 3,600.00 144,000.00 464,400.00 Employee Only $60 155 60.00 720.00 111,600.00 Emp Contrib 119 60.00 720.00 85,680.00 197,280.00 Total Employee Contribution 661,680.00 UNFUNDED AMOUNT 88,320.00 HRA CARD /CO Contribution 200,000.00 COUNTY CONTRIBUTION 288,320.00 HICI4 .00 60 L w Nr 10 0 0 O O O O O 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 O 0 0 0 O O O 0 0 0 O O O O O O O O O O O O O 0 0 0 O O O O O O O 0 O O co 0 0 0 O O O O O O O O O O O O CD CD 0 0 C 0 0 00 00 0000 CO O O O CO CO O0 COO O et CD CO lD NNOlO �CC)aD C) O CO CO � �OOD w W s } O N OD Pf O l t0 3 O 0 O CD N CD CD O O 1- N1' erO d' 10 Of 41. F l T- 10 CO V M .M.. 01 CO T0 0 0 0 T 0 0 0 O 0 0 0 0 O O O O O O O C 01 ( CO O N N C ' COO 01 0 N CC F ch c6 a-- a C O ch V O O 0 O O 0 0 O O O _ T CS CS CS CS 0 _T 11) O 10 O O L COO Co C O h O O' L CO P) 10 r r C C O o N 0) 0 OD O N C V 1 10 0 T- C C 0 0 o • a c a c a c c a 0 on C 0 0 tD R'U 0 0 C 0 0 0 zU CD � 0 ` 0 0 c0 c m; 0 c c °. a c E o= I i to O W W 7 1. 0 1 CO 0 W W 7 I 0 T- N ( 0 0 0 0 O O O Co g O D 0 O O O O O O O O O O 0 0 0 O O O O 0 0 0 0 O O O O O O O O • O • O O O O O O CO O O O O 0 0 0 O O 0 O O O O O 0 0 0 CS CS O O O O N 0 O O 0 O O O 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 O 0 0 0 7 0 0 0 CD OHO R c) NI- er M ONO O 00 0000 O eg N ON 0000 CO 0 O OD a COO CO N O O N 0) 10 00 O 0) CD CO O CD CD N CO C9 O M 1'- CO CO 0) (O CD N t0 (0 O Ch 0 160 CO 0110 O h 8 NG w CDC X10 ti � OD 000 - a 0)OO 0) ,- 10 A COP>0 0 11) 0) CO 00 N(0 O Ns O N 0 0 O , - V' 10 0 0) 0 00 0 h ,- (O 10 l O 0) 10 0) O CA 1. ' I- 01 T- (0 01 F N, 'C! T - T- CO N 01 F- l Nr e- — CO 01 N O O O O O O O 0 O O • O O O O O _ 0 0 0 0 0 _ 0 0 0 O O _ 0 0 0 O O m 0 C O O O CD c O 00 NN c N O N N N C Nr CD O CD CD C N CD CD Ns Ns C Nr CD R h Ns CC u) N c") a C 0) 0) c C 0)C O 0 0 0 0 O 0 o O 0 0 O O O 0 O L )NN h h t SS C C` 1q ') OM C C L h 2 o o C ■ 1 N c V OD W N C0 (0 W N C0 V 10 CO C C a c c o -z a C c a a0 Z r. .0 a 17 ' 1- 0 0 c 0 ,� 0- b 0 m C m F 0 C O U 0 C) R t m 0 7 )N0 t, C > < T E B.0 o �. cw�0 0 a Q tn 73 p W CU m = ' � O OU W =UZ 0 U CU-1 E o 0-a � a 0 o E o as w LL 7 E o 0. 0. w F LL CO W W F S0H U. U) W W F D=O 11.100 W W 7